Taqueria El Maguey
Hours not recordedTaqueria · New York, NY
Taqueria El Maguey is a taqueria in New York, NY at 3917 4th Ave. Hours not recorded. Call +1-347-689-2287. Directions and full hours below.
- Address
- 3917 4th Ave, 11232
- Phone
- +1-347-689-2287
- Website
- www.restauranttaqueriaelmaguey.com
- Type
- Taqueria · independent
About Taqueria El Maguey
Taqueria El Maguey is a taqueria, so expect a short, meat-forward menu, corn tortillas, and salsas made in house rather than a broad sit-down Mexican menu. It sits in New York (11232), NY, independently run.
There is no star rating on file for Taqueria El Maguey yet, so it is ranked here on how taco-focused it is (a taqueria scores above a general restaurant) and how complete its public listing is, not on reviews.
If a trompo is turning, order al pastor. Otherwise asada or carnitas is the safe read. Ask for everything con todo and work the salsa bar.
It is on 4th Ave in New York. Use the Directions button for turn-by-turn.
Call ahead or check the map listing before a special trip. Small taquerias change hours often, and our data refreshes on a schedule, not live.
In our New York taco guide, Taqueria El Maguey is ranked #110 of 445, by taco specialisation and listing completeness. How we rank.
What to expect on the menu
We do not have Taqueria El Maguey’s exact menu on file, so this is what a taqueria of this kind typically serves, not a guarantee of today’s board:
- Al pastor, when there is a trompo turning
- Carne asada and carnitas
- Pollo, and often suadero, lengua or cabeza
- Corn tortillas, doubled
- A salsa bar with onion, cilantro, lime and two or three house salsas
For the real menu and prices, use the venue’s site or the Google listing.
Opening hours
No opening hours on record for this venue. Call before you travel.
Menu
The current menu, prices and photos are on www.restauranttaqueriaelmaguey.com. You can also search Taqueria El Maguey on Google or open its Google Maps listing for the menu, dish photos and recent reviews.
Nearby alternatives in New York
- Dos Toros TaqueriaSee hoursCallDirections
- Dos Toros TaqueriaSee hoursCallDirections
- Dos Toros TaqueriaSee hoursCallDirections
- Dos Toros TaqueriaSee hoursCallDirections
- Dos Toros TaqueriaSee hoursCallDirections
- Dos Toros TaqueriaSee hoursCallDirections
Get directionsSee all 445 taco spots in New York →
Taqueria El Maguey: common questions
Is Taqueria El Maguey open right now?
We do not have opening hours on record for Taqueria El Maguey, so check its Google listing or call +1-347-689-2287 before you go.
Where is Taqueria El Maguey?
Taqueria El Maguey is a taqueria at 3917 4th Ave, 11232 in New York, NY. Use the Directions button for turn-by-turn from where you are.
How much do tacos cost at Taqueria El Maguey?
We do not have prices on file for Taqueria El Maguey. As a rule, a taqueria in New York runs a few dollars a taco. Check its menu link for current pricing.
Does Taqueria El Maguey do takeout or delivery?
Not on record. Most taquerias do takeout at the counter; for delivery, check DoorDash or Uber Eats for your address.
Is Taqueria El Maguey a chain?
No, Taqueria El Maguey is independently run, not part of a chain.
How is Taqueria El Maguey ranked?
Taqueria El Maguey is #110 of 445 taco spots we track in New York, ordered by how taco-focused a place is and how complete its listing is. Nobody pays for placement. Full method on our How We Rank page.
Is this your restaurant, or spotted something wrong? The fastest fix is the OpenStreetMap record, or send us the correction. No charge to claim or update a listing.
Last updated September 17, 2026. Venue details refresh with each data import.